Chocolatey goodness with a hint of cinnamon, crunchy tiny marshmallows and a marshmallow swirl
Slippery Sleighride
Sweet cream ice cream with a swirl of brownie batter, caramel and graham cracker cream. Enjoy the ride!
Evergreen Avalanche
A medley of spearmint and peppermint ice cream with double chocolate cookie dough pieces, Oreo pieces and a swirl of cookie fudge
Red Raspberries & Cream
Red raspberry ice cream and sweet cream ice cream together with a red raspberry drizzle
Peanut Butter Chip
Creamy peanut butter ice cream with soft chocolate pieces throughout
Tipsy Grandma
Butterscotch ice cream with a bit of rum with some of our yummy oatmeal raisin cookies and a swirl of more butterscotch, because we know that's just how you like it
Lumps of Coal
Dark chocolate ice cream with homemade Oreo truffles and a cookie fudge swirl
Holy Cannoli
Cannoli cream ice cream with pieces of cannoli shells ans tiny chocolate chips
Wildman's Toffee Hazelnut
Hazelnut ice cream swirled with Nutella and Heath toffee bits
Vegan Berries & Brownies
A berry vegan ice cream featuring black raspberry & strawberry flavors with pieces of gluten & dairy free brownies
Vegan Cherry Walnut
Vegan coconut cake ice cream with sweet cherries, maple walnuts and toasted coconut
NSA Vanilla Cherry
No-sugar-added vanilla ice cream with chunks of sweet dark cherries
Roasted Grape Sorbet
Roasted red grapes blended with a sherbet base (dairy & gluten free)
Smooth maple ice cream made with Andersen Farms homemade syrup and pieces of maple candied bacon (gluten-free)
Give Me S'more
Chocolate ice cream with toasted marshmallows, marshmallow swirl, dark chocolate chunks and graham cracker pieces
Matt's Butterfinger Nutter Butter
Vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter cookie swirl and pieces of Butterfinger candy
Dutchman's Delight
It's back! Sweet cream ice cream sprinkled with special spices, swirled with caramel and pieces of Holland American Bakery's Speculaas cookies (contains nuts)
Wildman's Toffee Hazelnut
Hazelnut ice cream swirled with Nutella and Heath toffee bits
Spooky
A super scary black dark chocolate ice cream with a cookie swirl, mini chocolate chips, brownie bites and chocolate covered pretzel nibs
Vegan Pumpkin Pie
CocanOat® based ice cream with Andersen Farms pumpkin butter and what else? Pumpkin! (dairy-free & gluten-free)
Vegan Chai
Vegan ice cream made with a CocanOat® base, steeped with chai tea and a few extra spices!
Pumpkin Spice
We wait all year for the leaves to fall so we can all things PUMPKIN SPICE! (gluten-free)
Cardamom Crisp
Cardamom ice cream with homemade apple, pear and cranberry crisp
NSA Milk & Cookies
No-sugar-added sweet cream ice cream sweetened with Splenda, folded together with pieces of sugar-free fudge brownie cookies and sugar-free chocolate chip cookies
Lemon Chiffon
A refreshing lemon ice cream with a hint of vanilla... so smooth! (gluten-free)
You Mocha Me Crazy
Chocolatey mocha ice cream with fudge brownie pieces, Oreo pieces and cookie dough
Lemon Chiffon
Refreshing lemony vanilla ice cream
Summer Peach
Probably the BEST peach ice cream you've ever had!
Home of the Brave
Angel food cake ice cream with pieces of homemade hot milk cake, fresh blueberries & fresh strawberries
Tiger Stripes
Vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter and fudge swirl
Razzmonade Sorbet
Homemade raspberry lemonade sorbet (dairy-free)
Vegan Party People
Party cake flavored CocanOat® base ice cream, colored with Spirulina to make it a fun blue, loaded with natural dye sprinkles & allergen-free chocolate chunks (soy & dye free + gluten free)
Vegan Bikini Bottom
Tropical fruit vegan ice cream made with a CocanOat® base to create a banana, coconut, orange and pineapple blend (gluten free)
NSA Double Chocolate Chip
No-sugar-added chocolate ice cream with sugar-free chocolate chunks
Vegan Tree Hugger
A coconut & cinnamon flavored CocanOat® based ice cream with granola, almond slivers, raisins and dried cranberries
Shark Attack
Blue Moon ice cream (kinda tastes like cotton candy & Fruity Pebbles) with mini gummy sharks, tiny Swedish fish, sour patch kids & sprinkles
Banana Cream Pie
Creamy banana ice cream blended with bits of Nilla Wafers, graham crackers and a marshmallow swirl
Apricot Honey
Andersen Farms apricot jam and clover honey blended together in a smooth ice cream. Tastes like a warm Spring day!
Cottontails
Lightly flavored cotton candy ice cream with cotton candy crunch and tiny fluffy marshmallows
Buttermint
Melt-in-your-mouth, buttery, minty ice cream!
Chocolate PB Brownie
Chocolate ice cream with pieces of peanut butter brownies, Reese's Pieces and a Reese's peanut butter swirl.
Blueberry Cheesecake
Smooth cheesecake ice cream with a blueberry swirl, pieces of cheesecake and a graham cracker swirl.
Marshmallow Dream
Sweet dreams cream with teeny tiny marshmallows, mini marshmallows and a marshmallow swirl!
Vegan Chai
Vegan ice cream made with a CocanOat® base, steeped with chai tea and a few extra spices!
Vegan Grasshopper
Vegan mint ice cream with a fudge swirl and gluten-free Oreo pieces (dairy-free & gluten-free)
NSA Coffee
No-sugar-added coffee ice cream
Vegan PB Cookie
Vegan peanut butter ice cream with a peanut butter swirl and homemade vegan gluten-free peanut butter cookie pieces
NSA Chocolate Almond Shortbread
No-sugar-added chocolate ice cream with sugar-free dark chocolate chips, tiny almond pieces and sugar-free almond shortbread cookies.
Monkey Business
Creamy banana ice cream with a peanut butter swirl and chocolate chunks
Marriage (aka Rocky Road)
Chocolate ice cream with a fudge swirl, loaded with walnuts and marshmallows. A little rocky at times, but it can be oh, so sweet!
Strawberries & Cream
Sweet cream ice cream with a swirl of strawberry... simple & sweet!
Caramel Latte
Sweet cream and espresso ice creams folded together with a caramel swirl
"I Love You"
White chocolate ice cream with Gertrude Hawk raspberry cups, brownie bits and a red raspberry swirl
Rose Water Pistachio
Delicately flavored rose water ice cream with a homemade pistachio cream and flakes of pink white chocolate
NSA Butter Pecan
No-sugar-added base made with Splenda and homemade toasted pecans (gluten-free)
NSA Milk & Cookies
No-sugar-added sweet cream ice cream sweetened with Splenda, folded together with pieces of sugar-free fudge brownie cookies and sugar-free chocolate chip cookies
Pa-Rum-Pum-Pum-Pum Raisin
Mulled spice rum raisin folded into a butter rum ice cream. Makes ya want to beat a drum-pum-pum-pum!
Bear in the Backyard
Rich chocolate ice cream with pieces of Amish hard pretzels, chocolate covered pretzel nibs and a caramel swirl
Yellow Snow
Our very own homemade lemon sorbet.
Snow Pudding
A refreshing combination of our Yellow Snow lemon sorbet and vanilla ice cream.
Reindeer Tracks
A winter wonderland of vanilla ice cream with a marshmallow swirl, Christmas sprinkles, brownie bites, fluffy marshmallows and candy cane crunch.
Red Cherry Chip
If you love the flavor of cherry pie or a cherry lollipop, then you will love our homemade red cherry ice cream with chocolate chips!
Give Me S'more
Chocolate ice cream with toasted marshmallows, marshmallow swirl, dark chocolate chunks and graham cracker pieces
Matt's Butterfinger Nutter Butter
Vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter cookie swirl and pieces of Butterfinger candy
Maple Candied Bacon
Smooth maple ice cream made with Andersen Farms homemade syrup and pieces of maple candied bacon (gluten-free)
Lemon Chiffon
A refreshing lemon ice cream with a hint of vanilla... so smooth! (gluten-free)
Apple Cranberry Sorbet
A delicious mix of apple and cranberry (dairy-free & gluten free)
Pear Sorbet
Crisp and refreshing homemade pear sorbet (dairy-free & gluten-free)
Pumpkin Spice
We wait all year for the leaves to fall so we can all things PUMPKIN SPICE! (gluten-free)
Vegan Pumpkin Pie
CocanOat® based ice cream with Andersen Farms pumpkin butter and what else? Pumpkin! (dairy-free & gluten-free)
Zucchini Bread
Cinnamon ice cream with pieces of Andersen Farms zucchini bread and shreds of fresh zucchini
Summer Peach
Probably the BEST peach ice cream you've ever had!
Boston Cream Pie
Vanilla custard ice cream with homemade milk cake and a fudge swirl
Lemon Meringue Pie
Creamy lemon ice cream with graham cracker pieces and a marshmallow swirl
Give Me a Break
A creamy malted chocolate ice cream with pieces of Kit Kat candy inside
Summer Smash Pie
Clove Brook Bakery's Summer Smash Pie swirled right into our homemade vanilla ice cream.
Blueberry Toasted Coconut
Coconut ice cream swirled with a delicious blueberry compote and toasted coconut flakes
Choco-Nana
Banana ice cream with chocolate chunks
Mango Sorbet
Homemade mango sorbet (dairy-free)
Nutty for Cookie Dough
Creamy peanut butter ice cream with cookie dough pieces and mini chocolate chips
Razzmonade Sorbet
Homemade raspberry lemonade sorbet (dairy-free)
Strawnanaberry
It's strawberry banana ice cream!
Vegan Death by Chocolate
Vegan chocolate ice cream with chocolate chunks, mini chips and a fudge swirl
Home of the Brave
Angel food cake ice cream with pieces of homemade hot milk cake, fresh blueberries & fresh strawberries
Blueberry Pomegranate Sorbet
You guessed it... blueberries & pomegranate mingling in a sweet sorbet — made with Andersen Farms blueberry jam (dairy free)
Lemon Chiffon
A refreshing lemon ice cream with a hint of vanilla... so smooth!
Cottontails
A really yummy cotton candy ice cream with a pink and purple cotton candy crunch.
"I Love You"
White chocolate ice cream with Gertrude Hawk raspberry cups, brownie bits and a red raspberry swirl
Ms. Saman's Crème Brûlée
Smooth and creamy crème brûlée custard ice cream with pieces and dust of caramelized sugar
Mango Sorbet
Homemade mango sorbet made with Andersen Farms mango jam
Watermelon Sorbet
Delicious homemade dairy-free sorbet made with fresh watermelon and a hint of lime
Corn Dog
Sweet corn ice cream made with our own fresh-picked corn swirled with homemade corn bread and bits of homemade candied hot dogs! Honestly, it's delicious!
Vegan Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Vegan strawberry ice cream with a delicious fudge swirl
No-Sugar-Added Peanut Butter Cups & Fudge
No sugar added vanilla ice cream with NSA Gertrude Hawk peanut butter cups & NSA peanut butter fudge pieces
Year-Round Flavors
Vanilla
Well... it's vanilla!
Chocolate
Tastes like chocolate!
Strawberry
Creamy berriness made with Andersen Farms jam!
Double Cookies & Cream
Sweet cream ice cream with Oreo pieces and cookie dough chunks
Mint Chip
Minty goodness with dark chocolate chunks, pieces & bits
Judy's Coffee
Because we love our neighbor Judy and Judy likes just coffee – nothin' in it!
Pop's Chocolate Chip
Vanilla ice cream with chunks and mini chocolate chips
Black Raspberry Triple Chocolate Chunk
Black raspberry ice cream with chocolate chunks
Dutchman's Delight
It's back! Sweet cream ice cream sprinkled with special spices, swirled with caramel and pieces of Holland American Bakery's Speculaas cookies (contains nuts)
Farmer's Favorite
Coconut ice cream with a caramel swirl, toasted coconut flakes, dark chocolate chunks and pieces of sugar cookies
Muddy Boots
Dark chocolate ice cream with Oreo truffles and a fudge cookie swirl. You might also know it as "Lumps of Coal"!
Greta's Goat Tracks
Chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate pieces, marshmallow swirl and Gertrude Hawk caramel cups
Tiger Stripes
Vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter and fudge swirl
Muddy Boots
The ice cream formerly known as Lumps of Coal (if Prince can do it, so can we!) Dark chocolate ice cream with homemade Oreo truffles and a cookie fudge swirl
Chocolate Covered Grasshopper
Mint ice cream with a fudge and cookie swirl, Andes Candies, mini chocolate chips and Oreo pieces
Dutchman's Delight
Sweet cream ice cream with pieces of Holland American Bakery's Speculaas Cookies, caramel swirl and a sprinkle of spices (contains nuts)
Party Time
Vanilla ice cream with birthday bits & pieces
Sugar-Free Flavors
NSA Vanilla Cherry
No-sugar-added vanilla ice cream with chunks of sweet dark cherries
NSA Mint Patty
No-sugar-added chocolate ice cream with sugar-free smooth mint patty pieces
NSA Butter Pecan
No-sugar-added base made with Splenda and homemade toasted pecans (gluten-free)
NSA Strawberry Almond Cookie
No-sugar-added strawberry ice cream with a hint of almond and pieces of sugar-free almonette cookies
NSA Double Chocolate Chip
No-sugar-added chocolate ice cream with sugar-free chocolate chunks
NSA Chocolate Almond Shortbread
No-sugar-added chocolate ice cream with sugar-free dark chocolate chips, tiny almond pieces and sugar-free almond shortbread cookies.
NSA Double Chocolate Chip
No-sugar-added chocolate ice cream with sugar-free chocolate chunks
NSA Chocolate Almond Shortbread
No-sugar-added chocolate ice cream with sugar-free dark chocolate chips, tiny almond pieces and sugar-free almond shortbread cookies.
NSA Chocolate Chip with Choco Chunks
No-sugar-added vanilla ice cream with sugar-free chocolate chunks
NSA Black Forest
No-sugar-added dark chocolate ice cream with sugar-free dark chocolate chips and a black cherry swirl
Sugar-Free Mint Bliss
A Splenda-based take on mint chocolate chip
NSA Coffee
No-sugar-added coffee ice cream
Vegan Non-Dairy Flavors
Vegan Berries & Brownies
CocanOat® based ice cream with Andersen Farms pumpkin butter and what else? Pumpkin! (dairy-free & gluten-free)
Vegan Cherry Maple
Vegan coconut cake ice cream with sweet cherries, maple walnuts and toasted coconut
Vegan Coffee Break
Coffee flavored CocanOat® based ice cream with pieces of gluten-free Oreos (gluten free)
Vegan Party People
Party cake flavored CocanOat® base ice cream, volored with Spirulina to make it a fun blue, loaded with natural dye sprinkles & allergen-free chocolate chunks (soy & dye free + gluten free)
Roasted Grape Sorbet
Roasted red grapes blended with a sherbet base (dairy & gluten free)
Brother Beans cold brew coffee with vanilla ice cream and whipped cream
Make-Your-Own Milkshake
Create a milkshake from any of our homemade ice cream flavors
Ice Cream Flights
Can't decide what flavor you want? Choose any 5 ice cream flavors and we will scoop them into tiny cups with lids and pack them into a cute little box to take home!
Want ice cream at your next event? We offer party favor cups with lids that make ice cream parties easy and fun! Call for more information.
